Case Study
Turning Tax Complexity into Cash Recovery
How Broniec Associates helped a nonprofit healthcare network recover more than $1.85 million by examining sales and use tax accruals, identifying overlooked financial opportunities, and reinforcing the value of invoice-level accuracy within an already disciplined accounts payable operation.
Client Context
A Disciplined AP Operation Facing Complex Tax Decisions
A nonprofit, integrated healthcare delivery network serving the southeastern United States operates five hospital campuses with more than 1,000 licensed acute care beds. The organization manages extensive purchasing and payment activity across a complex supplier network.
The healthcare system maintained an active and disciplined accounts payable department. Its established processes successfully limited duplicate payment exposure, demonstrating that many traditional AP controls were functioning effectively.
However, the organization faced a different financial challenge. Sales and use tax accruals were guided by a largely manual vendor matrix that determined tax treatment. Although the approach was consistent and reasonable overall, taxability could vary based on individual invoice lines, software delivery methods, and general ledger coding.
Unapplied vendor credits presented an additional concern. Credits left unresolved represented cash unavailable for other purposes, potentially affecting liquidity and financial efficiency. Broniec's audit addressed these opportunities while respecting the strengths of the client's existing financial processes.
The Challenge
Hidden Tax Over-Accruals Within a High-Volume AP Environment
Despite disciplined accounts payable processing and relatively limited duplicate payment exposure, the healthcare system faced financial risks that conventional AP controls did not fully address. Sales and use tax over-accruals and unresolved vendor credits created recovery opportunities within billions of dollars in spend.
Reliance on a Manual Vendor Tax Matrix
The organization relied largely on a manual vendor matrix to guide taxability decisions. Although the methodology was consistent and generally sound, applying tax treatment at the vendor level could overlook exceptions on individual invoices.
Invoice-Level Taxability Differences
Tax treatment could vary by invoice line item, software delivery method, and general ledger coding. Certain purchases were non-taxable even when their vendors were properly classified overall.
Large Transaction and Spending Volumes
The healthcare network processed substantial financial activity across multiple campuses and suppliers. Reviewing use tax accuracy required identifying material exceptions within a high-volume transaction environment.
Potential Over- and Under-Accruals
The vendor matrix presented potential exposure in both directions. An effective review needed to identify recoverable over-accruals without overlooking whether the existing approach created broader under-accrual concerns.
Unapplied Credits and Trapped Cash
Credits that remained unapplied represented funds unavailable for productive use. These balances could affect financial liquidity and did not generate interest while they remained unresolved.
Preserving Effective Existing Controls
The AP department already demonstrated strong discipline in limiting duplicate payments. The challenge was to uncover additional recovery opportunities without introducing unnecessary changes to processes that were already functioning effectively.
Sound accounts payable operations do not eliminate every source of financial leakage. In this case, the greatest opportunity was not duplicate payments but tax accrual precision and unapplied vendor credits. The audit needed to identify recoverable amounts while validating the integrity of the client's overall tax methodology.
The Broniec Approach
Precision-Based Tax Review Without Disrupting Existing AP Operations
Broniec conducted a detailed review of use tax accrual accuracy within the framework of its standard accounts payable audit methodology. The review was designed to integrate with existing workflows, prioritize material financial exposure, and distinguish individual taxability exceptions from broader vendor classification issues.
Apply a Materiality Threshold
Broniec applied a minimum invoice threshold of $1,000 to concentrate the audit on material exposures. This helped direct research toward transactions with meaningful recovery potential while maintaining an efficient review process.
Analyze Invoice-Level Tax Accuracy
Auditors reviewed use tax accruals at the invoice level, recognizing that a vendor could be correctly classified overall while certain purchases or line items qualified for different tax treatment.
Investigate Specific Taxability Exceptions
The review considered differences associated with invoice line items, electronically delivered software, and general ledger classifications. This targeted analysis helped identify over-accruals without broadly recategorizing vendors.
Reinforce Recovery and Credit Resolution
Alongside tax analysis, the audit addressed financial recovery opportunities associated with unresolved credits. The broader engagement supported practical improvements in vendor statement review and credit processing.
Transactions analyzed for use tax accrual accuracy in one year.
Associated transaction spend reviewed during that annual tax accrual analysis.
Rather than treating every vendor as incorrectly classified, Broniec focused on the individual transactions where taxability differed. This precision-based methodology helped identify significant recovery opportunities, limit unnecessary audit risk, and validate the client's underlying accrual methodology.
Findings & Results
More Than $1.85 Million Recovered Through Targeted Financial Review
Broniec's audit delivered substantial financial recoveries, with sales and use tax representing the overwhelming majority of the results. Equally important, the findings confirmed that the client's tax accrual methodology was fundamentally sound, while revealing specific transactions eligible for more accurate treatment and recovery.
Tax Recovery Became the Primary Source of Value
Sales and use tax recoveries exceeded $1.5 million, accounting for most of the overall result. The findings demonstrated how invoice-specific tax exceptions could produce meaningful recovery opportunities even when traditional duplicate payment exposure remained low.
Tax-Related Recoveries
More than $1.5 million was recovered through sales and use tax review, highlighting the value of examining individual invoices rather than relying exclusively on vendor-level classifications.
Limited Tax Chargeback Overstatements
Tax chargeback overstatements were limited to 1.3%, with electronically delivered software licenses identified as the primary contributing factor. These findings supported a focused approach to correction.
Confidence in Existing Tax Processes
The review confirmed that the organization's overall accrual methodology was sound, providing leadership with assurance that identified recoveries were not concealing systemic under-accrual risk.
Greater Financial Discipline Beyond Tax Recovery
More Consistent Vendor Statement Review
By the most recent audit, vendor statements were being reviewed more diligently, helping the client improve visibility into outstanding supplier balances and unresolved credit opportunities.
Faster Credit Posting and Lower Unapplied Balances
Credits were being posted more quickly, and unapplied balances had declined significantly. This progress supported better cash flow visibility and reduced the amount of value remaining unresolved in vendor accounts.
The engagement demonstrated that comprehensive AP recovery auditing can produce significant financial results without finding widespread failures in existing controls. By isolating invoice-level tax exceptions, validating the client's accrual framework, and reinforcing credit management practices, Broniec helped turn tax complexity into measurable cash recovery and stronger financial visibility.
Total reported recoveries were $1,854,356.86. Sales and use tax recoveries exceeded $1.5 million. The source reports tax chargeback overstatements of 1.3% but does not specify the precise denominator for that percentage; it is therefore presented without extrapolation.
Let's Start a Conversation
Could Tax Over-Accruals Be Hiding in Your AP Data?
Even organizations with strong accounts payable controls can overlook recoverable sales and use tax, unresolved vendor credits, and invoice-level financial discrepancies. Broniec Associates helps organizations evaluate payment accuracy, investigate tax-related opportunities, and strengthen visibility into financial risk.
A targeted, independent review can help uncover financial opportunities while reinforcing confidence in established accounts payable processes.
