Case Study
Three Systems. Eight Currencies. Countless Wins.
How Broniec Associates helped a leading electronics manufacturer navigate fragmented financial systems, eight currencies, complex invoice references, and ERP migration challenges to uncover overlooked payment discrepancies and strengthen accounts payable accuracy across North American operations.
Client Context
Complex Manufacturing Operations Across Three Countries
A leading electronics manufacturer with production plants across the United States, Canada, and Mexico engaged Broniec Associates to address growing complexity in its accounts payable environment. The organization managed substantial supplier activity across regions, financial systems, and currencies.
SAP and Lawson operated simultaneously, with distinct data structures and invoice formatting conventions. Supporting documentation was also distributed between SAP and SpyVision, complicating the validation of historical payment activity.
Vendor spending involved eight currencies, creating further challenges in reconciliation and payment accuracy. Evaluated Receipt Settlement (ERS) transactions introduced alternate reference numbers that made some duplicate payments difficult to identify through conventional matching.
Plant closures, financial system migrations, and staff turnover added to the operational demands. As the company transitioned from JDE/Mapics to SAP, Broniec adapted its auditing approach to support payment validation while the client's processes and system environments continued to evolve.
The Challenge
When Multiple Systems Obscure Payment Accuracy
The manufacturer's accounts payable environment presented overlapping risks from multiple ERP systems, eight currencies, inconsistent payment references, and fragmented supporting documentation. Plant closures, system migrations, and staffing changes added further complexity, allowing discrepancies to evade normal internal controls.
Simultaneous ERP Systems
SAP and Lawson operated with different formatting rules and data structures. Comparing invoices, payments, and vendor records across both environments required additional analysis to identify discrepancies hidden by system variation.
Eight-Currency Processing
Vendor spend extended across eight currencies. This increased the complexity of comparing payment amounts and introduced potential exposure to conversion variances and reconciliation errors.
ERS Reference Number Limitations
Evaluated Receipt Settlement transactions generated alternate reference numbers. These references complicated duplicate payment identification, particularly when matching invoices and payment activity across financial systems.
Fragmented Supporting Documentation
Payment-related documentation was divided between SAP and SpyVision. The separation created gaps in audit trails and slowed verification of invoices, credits, and other supplier activity.
Operational and Staffing Disruptions
Plant closures, staff turnover, and system migrations created inconsistent processing practices and AP continuity challenges. These transitions increased the difficulty of maintaining consistent controls across locations.
Migration-Related Payment Exposure
The transition from JDE/Mapics to SAP introduced risks involving mismatched references, duplicate postings, and incomplete vendor master conversions. These potential defects required attention during the system change.
When systems, currencies, and payment references are inconsistent, duplicate payments, missed credits, freight discrepancies, and pricing errors can remain hidden from routine financial controls. The client needed an independent audit capable of evaluating transactions across multiple environments without interrupting ongoing operations.
The Broniec Approach
System-Specific Analysis Across Regions, Currencies, and Payment Categories
Broniec deployed experienced auditors familiar with multi-system accounts payable environments to conduct a comprehensive review across the client's operating regions. Advanced data-mining techniques helped reconcile inconsistent invoice formats, match ERS-based references, and investigate discrepancies that conventional comparisons could miss.
Reconcile Multi-System Payment References
Broniec applied data-mining techniques to align inconsistent invoice formats and ERS-based identifiers. This enabled auditors to identify potential duplicate and erroneous payments obscured by differing system conventions.
Review Credits, Pricing, and Discounts
The comprehensive audit examined unapplied credits, open balances, pricing and rate errors, missed trade discounts, and debit balance recovery opportunities across the client's operating regions.
Analyze Syncada Freight Data
Targeted analysis of Syncada freight records examined high-rate anomalies, unauthorized charges, and misapplied payments. This review helped identify freight discrepancies that exceeded contracted rates.
Adapt Auditing During ERP Migration
As the client moved from JDE/Mapics to SAP, Broniec adjusted its audit strategy to minimize disruption and identify migration-related risks involving reference mismatches, duplicate postings, and incomplete vendor master conversions.
Reviewing More Than Duplicate Payments
A multi-system, multi-currency AP environment requires more than standard duplicate invoice matching. Broniec's audit combined system-specific techniques, detailed freight analysis, and migration support to uncover discrepancies across diverse financial records while helping the client maintain continuity through organizational change.
Findings & Results
Uncovering AP Discrepancies Across Systems, Freight, and Supplier Accounts
Broniec identified discrepancies across multiple payment categories that had not been consistently detected by internal controls. The audit uncovered overpayments concealed by ERS references, freight billing variances, overlooked credits, and documentation issues that complicated transaction verification. The findings also highlighted opportunities to strengthen AP integrity during ERP migration.
Finding Discrepancies That System Differences Concealed
The review revealed payment errors and recoverable balances that were difficult to identify because of inconsistent reference formats, multiple systems, and fragmented documentation. These findings provided the client with a clearer understanding of risk areas across its regional AP operations.
ERS-Based Overpayments Identified
Broniec identified overpayments concealed by alternate ERS reference structures. Matching inconsistent transaction identifiers helped reveal errors that conventional invoice matching could overlook.
Freight Charges Exceeding Contracted Rates
Targeted freight analysis detected billing variances above contracted rates. Review of Syncada data also examined high-rate anomalies, unauthorized charges, and misapplied payments.
Overlooked Credits and Balances Recovered
The audit recovered credits and balances that had been overlooked because of fragmented financial systems. These findings reinforced the importance of reviewing supplier activity across separate environments.
Audit Trail Inconsistencies Highlighted
Broniec identified documentation inconsistencies affecting internal review and vendor reconciliation. These gaps helped explain why certain discrepancies were more difficult to validate through existing processes.
Supporting More Resilient AP Operations
Greater ERP Migration Awareness
The audit highlighted risks commonly associated with system transitions, including mismatched references, duplicate postings, and incomplete vendor master conversions.
Actionable Insight Across Regions
Broniec provided a clearer picture of payment discrepancies and process weaknesses across operating locations, supporting improvements to AP accuracy, verification, and control practices.
The engagement demonstrated the importance of system-specific auditing for manufacturers operating across multiple ERP environments and currencies. By identifying previously undetected discrepancies and supporting the client through financial system changes, Broniec helped improve payment accuracy, reduce exposure, and reinforce a more resilient accounts payable framework.
The source case study describes identified overpayments, recovered credits, freight billing discrepancies, and control improvements. It does not provide a total dollar amount for identified claims or recoveries. No financial recovery figure has been attributed to this engagement.
Let's Start a Conversation
Are Multiple ERP Systems Hiding Financial Discrepancies?
Multiple financial platforms, different currencies, ERP migrations, and inconsistent payment references can make overpayments and unresolved credits difficult to identify. Broniec Associates helps organizations navigate complex accounts payable environments through independent auditing, experienced analysis, and actionable financial insights.
A comprehensive AP recovery audit can help reveal discrepancies across systems, validate supplier balances, and strengthen controls during organizational and technology transitions.
