Case Study

Facilities Management First-Time AP Audit ERP Conversion

First-Time AP Audit Uncovered Millions

How a facilities management company uncovered more than $3.5 million in accounts payable claims after more than a decade without an independent recovery audit, revealing financial discrepancies across a complex environment shaped by ERP conversions, acquisitions, and shared services consolidation.

Total Claims Identified $3.5M+ Across 208 AP Audit Claims Findings included duplicate and erroneous payments, outstanding vendor credits, debit balances, and sales and use tax discrepancies.

Client Context

A Decade Without an AP Audit Amid Significant Operational Change

A U.S.-based facilities management company, operating as a subsidiary of an international parent organization, engaged Broniec Associates for its first external accounts payable recovery audit in more than a decade. The company contacted Broniec after its parent organization recommended an independent review of its AP operations.

During the initial discussions, company leadership revealed that its financial environment had undergone substantial changes. The organization had recently consolidated three separate PeopleSoft platforms into SAP while also acquiring a competitor whose payables remained within a separate SAP environment.

The company had also established a shared services center to address historically manual accounts payable processes. With more than $1.5 billion in spend and approximately 360,000 annual transactions, the department managed considerable processing demands and relied on temporary staff to support its workload.

Expectations for the audit varied among Purchasing leadership. One leader anticipated substantial recovery opportunities that could help fund strategic initiatives, while another expected minimal findings. This made clear documentation, verified claims, and transparent reporting particularly important throughout the engagement.

The Challenge

A Decade of Unreviewed AP Activity Amid Major Operational Change

More than 10 years had passed since the company's last accounts payable audit. During that time, the organization experienced significant financial system changes, acquisition activity, and restructuring of its AP operations. These transitions, combined with substantial transaction volumes, introduced potential discrepancies that had not been independently evaluated through a comprehensive recovery audit.

More Than a Decade Without an AP Audit

The company had not conducted a formal accounts payable recovery audit in more than 10 years. Without a recent independent review, leadership lacked confirmation of the extent of duplicate payments, erroneous disbursements, and outstanding vendor credits within its payment history.

Complex ERP Consolidation

The organization had recently converted three separate PeopleSoft platforms into SAP. Consolidating historical financial systems introduced complexity into the AP environment and created a need to evaluate payment accuracy across legacy and newly integrated processes.

Acquisition-Related System Fragmentation

The company had acquired a competitor whose accounts payable activity remained within a separate SAP environment. This added another layer of complexity to the organization's financial operations and required consideration of payment activity across distinct system environments.

High-Volume Payment Processing

With more than $1.5 billion in annual spend and approximately 360,000 transactions each year, the company's AP environment presented a substantial volume of financial activity to review. Identifying overlooked discrepancies required a structured approach beyond routine transaction processing.

Shared Services Transition and Staffing Demands

The organization had established a shared services center to address historically manual AP processes. At the same time, the department relied on temporary staff to manage processing demands. These operational changes made an independent assessment of payment accuracy and existing controls particularly valuable.

Differing Expectations Among Purchasing Leadership

Two Purchasing leaders entered the engagement with different expectations. One anticipated meaningful recoveries that could support strategic initiatives, while the other expected minimal findings. This underscored the importance of verified claims, comprehensive supporting documentation, and transparent reporting throughout the audit.

The Underlying Risk

ERP conversions, acquisitions, and shared services consolidation can fundamentally change how accounts payable transactions are processed and reviewed. For this company, the absence of a recovery audit for more than a decade meant potential overpayments and outstanding credits had not been independently assessed across a changing financial environment.

The Broniec Approach

Starting With a Focused Review, Expanding Through Proven Results

Broniec Associates began with a targeted accounts payable recovery audit focused on unidentified vendor credits and duplicate or erroneous payments. The engagement emphasized verified findings, supporting documentation, and transparent communication with Purchasing leadership. Strong early results led the client to extend its vendor statement review and expand the audit into additional recovery categories.

Initial Duplicate Payment and Vendor Credit Review

Broniec initiated the engagement with a defined scope covering unidentified vendor credits and duplicate or erroneous payments. This focused review provided an initial assessment of financial discrepancies within the client's high-volume accounts payable environment following major system and organizational changes.

Verified Claims and Transparent Reporting

Within days, Broniec identified and presented more than $20,000 in verified overpayments. Each finding was supported by documentation and made available through Broniec's secure Client Services System (CSS) portal. The client promptly reviewed and approved these items for recovery.

Extended Vendor Statement Review

Following the initial findings, the client authorized a four-month extension of the vendor statement review. This expanded the opportunity to examine supplier balances, validate outstanding credits, and identify additional amounts that had not been resolved through routine AP processing.

Expanded Debit Balance and Tax Review

The client also expanded the engagement to include debit balance items and sales and use tax. These additional categories broadened the review beyond the original payment and credit scope, allowing Broniec to identify further financial discrepancies across the organization's accounts payable activity.

$20K+ Verified Overpayments Identified Within Days

Early Findings Established Confidence in the Audit

The prompt identification of documented overpayments gave Purchasing leadership tangible evidence of previously undetected payment errors. With findings accessible through the CSS portal, the client could review supporting documentation and approve claims for recovery. These early results supported the decision to extend and expand the engagement.

Why This Approach Mattered

For an organization conducting its first recovery audit in more than a decade, documented early results were essential to demonstrating the value of independent review. By beginning with a focused scope and expanding based on verified findings, Broniec helped the client identify additional recovery opportunities while strengthening visibility into payment accuracy across multiple financial categories.

Findings & Results

More Than $3.5 Million in AP Claims Identified

What began as a focused review of duplicate payments and unidentified vendor credits developed into a broader recovery audit with significant findings. Broniec identified discrepancies across four audit categories, demonstrating the financial exposure that can accumulate when complex accounts payable operations go without an independent review.

Total AP Audit Findings $3.5M+ Across 208 Identified Claims

A First-Time Audit Revealed Substantial Financial Opportunities

Broniec identified 208 claims totaling more than $3.5 million across duplicate and erroneous payments, outstanding vendor credits, debit balances, and sales and use tax discrepancies. The findings provided documented evidence of opportunities that had gone undetected through routine AP processing.

Duplicate & Erroneous Payments $2.4M

Payment Discrepancies Identified

The largest category of audit findings involved duplicate and erroneous payments. These discrepancies highlighted financial risks within an environment shaped by ERP consolidation, acquisition activity, and high transaction volumes.

Outstanding Vendor Credits $1.0M

Unidentified Credits Uncovered

Vendor statement review identified approximately $1 million in outstanding credits. These findings demonstrated the importance of examining supplier balances beyond standard payment transactions to locate funds that had not been applied or otherwise resolved.

Debit Balance Review $79K

Additional Debit Balance Claims

Following the client's decision to broaden the audit scope, Broniec identified approximately $79,000 in debit balance findings. These additional claims demonstrated the value of evaluating recovery categories beyond the original engagement scope.

Sales & Use Tax $42K

Tax Discrepancies Identified

The expanded sales and use tax review uncovered approximately $42,000 in discrepancies. This additional category provided another source of financial opportunity and further insight into the client's accounts payable processes.

Early Results Created Momentum for a Broader Review

Verified Findings Within Days

Within days of beginning the audit, Broniec presented more than $20,000 in verified overpayments, each supported by documentation and available through the Client Services System (CSS) portal. The client quickly approved these items for recovery.

Expanded Audit Authorization

The strength of the initial findings prompted the client to extend the vendor statement review by four months and authorize additional reviews of debit balance items and sales and use tax. This decision expanded the opportunities identified through the engagement.

The Lasting Value

The audit demonstrated how substantial financial discrepancies can remain undetected in organizations experiencing ERP conversions, acquisitions, and changes to accounts payable operations. Beyond identifying more than $3.5 million in claims, Broniec provided the client with greater visibility into payment accuracy, unresolved vendor balances, and opportunities to strengthen controls and reduce recurring errors.

The $3.5 million figure represents more than 208 identified claims across the reviewed audit categories, not a confirmed cash recovery total. Category amounts are rounded as reported in the source case study.

Let's Start a Conversation

When Was Your Last Independent AP Recovery Audit?

System conversions, acquisitions, staffing transitions, and routine processing demands can leave financial discrepancies undetected for years. Broniec Associates helps organizations identify duplicate payments, unresolved vendor credits, and other recovery opportunities while gaining valuable insight into accounts payable controls.

An independent review can help reveal the financial opportunities and control weaknesses that everyday AP processing may not uncover.