Case Study

Waste Management AP Recovery Audit ERP & Acquisition Risk

Waste Management: Uncovering Hidden Losses

How Broniec Associates helped two major waste management providers identify hidden overpayments, investigate duplicate transactions across financial systems, and strengthen accounts payable controls during ERP migrations, acquisitions, and operational consolidation.

Significant Duplicate Payment $230K+ One Duplicate Claim Identified During ERP Migration A single payment was duplicated across two AP systems during the transition from Infinium to Workday. This finding relates to Client A.

Client Context

Two Waste Management Providers, Two Paths to Financial Complexity

Waste management organizations operate across geographically dispersed locations with substantial purchasing activity, multiple supplier accounts, and complex operational requirements. Acquisitions and financial system transitions can further complicate the accuracy of accounts payable records and vendor balances.

Broniec Associates conducted recovery audits for two major waste management providers facing different forms of operational change. Although their specific circumstances differed, both environments presented opportunities for duplicate payments, inconsistent financial records, and unresolved supplier balances.

Client A transitioned from Infinium to Workday while moving from decentralized payment operations to a centralized AP structure. Overlapping financial information between the two ERP systems created duplicate payment exposure during the migration.

Client B experienced repeated acquisition activity. Newly acquired entities continued operating under their original business names, while multiple ERP systems, manual processing, and inconsistent vendor information complicated payment and credit reconciliation.

Together, these engagements illustrate why independent recovery auditing remains valuable during organizational growth and system consolidation, even when internal processes are being modernized.

The Challenge

Hidden Payment Risk During ERP Migration and Acquisition-Driven Growth

Waste management operations combine substantial spending with geographically distributed locations, diverse suppliers, and frequent organizational changes. For the two audited providers, ERP transitions, acquisitions, and inconsistent financial records created conditions where duplicate payments and unresolved vendor credits could remain undetected.

Overlapping ERP Data During System Migration

Client A's transition from Infinium to Workday created overlapping financial information between the two systems. Payments duplicated across the environments were particularly difficult to detect through ordinary processing checks.

Acquisitions and Multiple Business Identities

Client B had acquired multiple businesses that continued to operate under their original names. This complicated vendor communication, account identification, and the correct routing of billing and credit activity.

Fragmented Vendor Account Information

Vendors servicing multiple locations often maintained several accounts. Determining whether an outstanding credit or payment belonged to the correct operating entity required additional reconciliation.

Manual Processing and Non-Invoice Documents

Manual invoice entry and reliance on quotes, sales orders, and service work orders introduced inconsistent transaction references. Variations in invoice numbers could contribute to duplicate or erroneous payments.

Aged and Unresolved Vendor Credits

Client B faced a substantial volume of outstanding credits. Inconsistent vendor communication and difficulty assigning balances to the correct entity complicated resolution, allowing credits to remain outstanding.

Unreliable Purchase Order and Pricing Records

System conversions and centralization weakened the reliability of some purchase order and pricing information for Client B. This made it harder to validate supplier charges and identify transaction discrepancies.

The Underlying Risk

Financial system changes and acquisitions can introduce discrepancies even when the objective is stronger centralization and control. These audits demonstrated the importance of validating historical payments, vendor identities, and outstanding balances across systems and business locations.

The Broniec Approach

Identifying Overpayments Across Systems, Locations, and Vendor Accounts

Broniec conducted AP recovery audits tailored to the different operational circumstances of the two providers. The work identified payments duplicated across financial systems and business locations, examined discrepancies associated with vendor accounts, and provided insight into processes requiring stronger controls during organizational change.

Identify Cross-System Duplicate Payments

For Client A, Broniec identified duplicate payment claims associated with overlapping information in Infinium and Workday. These findings highlighted the importance of reviewing payments across both legacy and newly implemented ERP environments.

Investigate Duplicate Vendor and Payment Activity

The reviews identified overpayments involving duplicate vendor accounts, payments made by both AP and purchasing cards, and payments issued by different divisions for the same vendor or service.

Examine Vendor Credits and Billing Inconsistencies

For Client B, the audit considered challenges involving aged credits, multiple vendor identities, manual data-entry errors, and difficulty assigning credits to the correct acquired entity.

Support AP Control Improvements

The findings informed process improvement opportunities. Client A implemented a weekly check-run review designed to identify unusual payment trends and potential duplicate transactions within its new centralized AP environment.

Two Distinct Audit Environments

Different Causes, Similar Financial Exposure

Client A: ERP Conversion Controls

Most recoveries were associated with duplicate payments during the system migration. Although the audit did not identify systemic risks, the client adopted a weekly check-run review to flag unusual trends and potential duplicates.

Client B: Acquisition and Vendor Account Complexity

Multiple ERP platforms, inconsistent vendor identities, manual invoice processing, and unreliable pricing information contributed to the complexity of identifying overpayments and resolving aged credits.

Why This Approach Mattered

Financial discrepancies can arise from different sources during periods of change. Client A's principal issue involved duplicate payments during ERP migration, while Client B faced fragmented vendor and financial information following acquisitions. Independent AP recovery auditing helped reveal those exposures and identify areas for stronger ongoing controls.

Findings & Results

Recovering Overpayments and Strengthening Controls Through Operational Change

Broniec's audits identified hidden financial losses across two distinct waste management environments. For Client A, duplicate payments during ERP migration represented the principal recovery category. For Client B, acquisition-related complexity contributed to overpayments, reconciliation challenges, and aged credits. Both reviews provided insight into improving AP controls.

Client A | Major Duplicate Claim $230K+ One Duplicate Payment Across Two ERP Systems

ERP Migration Created a Significant Duplicate Payment Opportunity

During the transition from Infinium to Workday, overlapping financial data resulted in duplicate payments. A single duplicate claim exceeded $230,000, demonstrating how system cutovers can create substantial exposure even as organizations move toward more centralized financial operations.

Client A | Recovery Findings

Duplicate Payments Drove Most Recoveries

Most of Client A's recoveries involved duplicate payments associated with overlapping data between Infinium and Workday. The audit did not reveal systemic risks, although several improvements were recommended.

Client A | Control Improvement

Weekly Check-Run Review Implemented

Client A implemented a weekly review of check runs to identify unusual trends and potential duplicate payments. This measure strengthened oversight within its newly centralized AP environment.

Client B | Payment Findings

Duplicate and Cross-Entity Payments Identified

Claims included payments made through both AP and purchasing cards, payments from separate divisions for the same vendor or service, and duplicate vendor accounts associated with the same payee.

Client B | Billing Discrepancies

Repeated Charges and Invoice Variations

Additional claims involved charges for the same product or service appearing on multiple invoices. In some instances, corrections to rates or quantities appeared as new invoices, complicating duplicate payment detection.

Common AP Risk Patterns Across Waste Management Operations

ERP Migration Risk

Data overlap and mismatched payment references during system conversion can conceal duplicate transactions.

Acquisition-Driven Complexity

New business entities introduce additional vendor identities, payment records, and statement activity requiring reconciliation.

Manual Entry Errors

Inconsistent invoice references and manual processing create opportunities for duplicate or misapplied payments.

Multiple Vendor Accounts

Suppliers serving several locations can maintain separate accounts that complicate payment and credit validation.

Aged Vendor Credits

Decentralized processes and unclear routing instructions can allow credits to remain unresolved for extended periods.

Value of Independent Review

Cross-system and cross-entity analysis can reveal errors that individual operating locations may not detect independently.

The Lasting Value

These engagements demonstrated how AP recovery auditing can uncover hidden financial losses while helping organizations understand the control weaknesses that arise during ERP migrations and acquisitions. By identifying duplicate payments and examining vendor account inconsistencies, Broniec helped both providers improve visibility and strengthen financial oversight during operational change.

The original case study reports one duplicate claim exceeding $230,000 for Client A. This is an individual claim amount, not the total recoveries for either client. No combined financial recovery total is provided for these two engagements.

Let's Start a Conversation

Are ERP Changes and Acquisitions Creating Hidden AP Exposure?

Financial system migrations, newly acquired operations, multiple vendor accounts, and decentralized payment activity can create opportunities for duplicate payments and unresolved credits. Broniec Associates helps organizations investigate these discrepancies, identify recoverable funds, and understand where additional financial controls may be needed.

Independent AP recovery auditing can help uncover overlooked financial discrepancies and strengthen oversight during periods of operational growth and change.