Case Study

Healthcare Vendor Credit Recovery AP Controls

Hidden Value in Credit Resolution and AP Discipline

How Broniec Associates helped an academic pediatric healthcare system recover more than $2.1 million across four audits, uncovering unresolved vendor credits, identifying recurring payment errors, and reinforcing essential accounts payable controls amid staffing changes and high transaction volumes.

Total Recoveries $2.1M+ Across Four AP Recovery Audits Recoveries were driven primarily by vendor credit resolution and correction of payment errors across a six-year fiscal period.

Client Context

A Specialized Healthcare Network With Complex AP and Vendor Relationships

A nonprofit, academic pediatric healthcare system provides highly specialized care to patients from birth through young adulthood. The organization operates a multi-hospital network with more than 600 licensed inpatient beds.

Its financial operations involve high transaction volumes and complex supplier relationships. Maintaining payment accuracy and resolving vendor credits are important to protecting cash flow and ensuring financial resources remain available to support patient care.

Over a six-year fiscal period, Broniec Associates partnered with the healthcare system through four accounts payable recovery audits. The reviews examined payment discrepancies, vendor credits, debit balances, and sales and use tax.

The hospital maintained strong purchasing card controls and generally accurate invoice processing. However, recurring AP-driven errors and unapplied vendor credits presented opportunities for financial recovery. Staff turnover and relatively short intervals between audits also made it difficult to fully implement earlier recommendations before subsequent reviews.

The Challenge

Recurring AP Errors and Credits That Remained Unresolved

Despite generally accurate invoice processing and effective purchasing card controls, the healthcare system continued to experience payment errors and unresolved vendor credits. Staff turnover and limited time to implement earlier audit recommendations contributed to recurring financial exposure.

Invoice Entry Inconsistencies

Variations in invoice numbering, use of revised invoices, and processing of documents that were not standard invoices created opportunities for duplicate and erroneous payments within traditional AP workflows.

Staff Turnover and Control Continuity

Changes in AP personnel complicated the consistent application of established controls. Turnover also affected the organization's ability to reinforce practices and address recurring payment errors between audits.

Limited Implementation Time Between Audits

The relatively short intervals between reviews made it difficult to fully implement previous recommendations. As a result, some underlying processing weaknesses remained and continued to generate discrepancies.

Vendor Credits Without Complete Supporting Detail

High-volume vendors sometimes confirmed outstanding credit balances without supplying the transaction details necessary to resolve them. This complicated reconciliation and made proactive supplier follow-up essential.

Years of Unresolved Credit Activity

The hospital maintained a sizeable checklist of unresolved credit items dating back eight years. These balances illustrated how credits can accumulate when follow-up and resolution are not consistently completed.

Rising Duplicate Payment Exposure

Duplicate and erroneous payment recoveries increased significantly. In the third audit, duplicate payment recoveries were 105.13% higher than in the preceding review, underscoring the importance of sustained control reinforcement.

The Underlying Risk

Financial exposure can grow even in AP environments with strong controls in some areas. For this healthcare system, recurring invoice processing errors and years of unresolved credits demonstrated the need for continued audit oversight, consistent staff education, and proactive vendor statement reconciliation.

The Broniec Approach

Combining Financial Recovery With Stronger AP Practices

Broniec's audits emphasized both financial recovery and client education. Detailed transaction analysis helped identify the underlying causes of payment errors, while vendor statement reconciliation focused on validating unresolved credits. Updated recommendations reinforced the importance of consistent controls throughout everyday AP processing.

Detailed Transaction Testing

Broniec examined AP activity to identify duplicate and erroneous payments, with particular attention to invoice entry inconsistencies and recurring processing errors.

Vendor Statement Reconciliation

The audit prioritized reconciliation of supplier statements and validation of unapplied credits. This work helped identify balances that remained unresolved despite ongoing AP processing activity.

Root-Cause Identification

Auditors examined invoice numbering variations, revised invoices, and the processing of non-invoice documents to understand why errors occurred and where existing system controls required reinforcement.

Refreshed Control Recommendations

Broniec provided updated recommendations focused on reinforcing embedded AP system controls and foundational processing practices. The work also emphasized education to help address recurring errors during periods of staff transition.

Supporting Audit Priorities

Addressing the Sources of Recurring Financial Exposure

Longstanding Credit Balances

The hospital's unresolved credit checklist included items dating back eight years, requiring careful attention to vendor statements and outstanding balances.

Supplier Confirmation

High-volume suppliers sometimes confirmed credit balances without full supporting detail. Proactive statement review was essential to investigating those balances.

Traditional AP Workflows

The audit concentrated on the processing activities where errors continued to arise rather than assuming every payment channel carried equal risk.

Sustained Control Discipline

Refreshed recommendations supported ongoing attention to invoice accuracy, payment validation, and credit management between audits.

Why This Approach Mattered

Recovering funds addressed the immediate financial exposure, but identifying the causes of recurring errors was equally important. By combining transaction testing, vendor reconciliation, and practical control recommendations, Broniec helped the healthcare system understand where AP discipline needed continued reinforcement.

Findings & Results

More Than $2.1 Million Recovered Through Credit Resolution and Payment Accuracy Reviews

Across four audits spanning a six-year fiscal period, Broniec delivered more than $2.1 million in recoveries. The majority resulted from resolving vendor credits and correcting payment errors, while the audit findings also highlighted opportunities to reinforce traditional AP controls and improve ongoing credit management.

Total Recoveries Across Four Audits $2,121,005 Recovered Across a Six-Year Fiscal Period

Recovering Value From Credits and Payment Errors

The majority of recoveries were driven by vendor credit resolution and correction of AP payment errors. These results demonstrated how longstanding unresolved balances and recurring processing issues can create substantial financial exposure even within an organization with generally effective purchasing controls.

Duplicate Payment Recoveries +105.13%

Increase Between Two Audits

Duplicate payment recoveries in the third audit were 105.13% higher than those in the preceding review, highlighting continued exposure to recurring AP processing errors.

Credit Recovery Opportunity 80%+

Open Credits Dominated Identified Credit Dollars

In the audit period cited by the original case study, open credits represented more than 80% of total credit dollars identified. This reinforced the importance of proactive vendor statement reconciliation.

Historical Credit Activity 8 Years

Outstanding Credits Dating Back Years

The hospital's unresolved credit checklist included items dating back eight years. This illustrated how balances can accumulate without systematic validation and supplier follow-up.

Important Findings Beyond the Recovery Total

Purchasing Card Controls Showed Minimal Exposure

Purchasing card activity demonstrated limited overpayment exposure. This helped confirm that the client's primary financial risks were concentrated in traditional AP processing rather than purchasing card programs.

Root Causes Informed Updated Recommendations

The audit identified invoice numbering variations, revised invoice processing, and non-invoice document handling as recurring sources of payment discrepancies. Broniec used these findings to refresh recommendations for reinforcing AP controls.

The Lasting Value

Recovering more than $2.1 million gave the pediatric healthcare system financial resources that could be redirected toward its mission. Equally important, the audit program demonstrated how resolving supplier credits and reinforcing fundamental AP practices can help reduce recurring errors and strengthen financial stewardship.

The $2,121,005 represents total reported recoveries across four audits. The 105.13% increase compares duplicate payment recoveries in the third audit with the preceding audit. The more-than-80% figure refers to the share of identified credit dollars attributable to open credits in a particular audit, not to the share of the entire $2.1 million recovery total.

Let's Start a Conversation

How Much Value Is Tied Up in Unresolved Vendor Credits?

Unapplied credits, recurring payment errors, and gaps in invoice processing can create substantial financial exposure, even in organizations with established AP controls. Broniec Associates helps organizations investigate outstanding balances, identify recovery opportunities, and strengthen the processes that support payment accuracy.

Proactive credit resolution and independent financial review can help return overlooked funds to your organization while reinforcing stronger accounts payable practices.