Case Study
Multinational AP Audit Delivers Results
How Broniec Associates helps a leading global manufacturer navigate decentralized purchasing, complex pricing structures, and internationally distributed suppliers, combining comprehensive AP recovery auditing with multilingual vendor outreach to strengthen financial accuracy across regions.
Client Context
Nearly Two Decades of Audit Support Across a Global Manufacturing Network
For almost 20 years, Broniec Associates has supported one of the world's leading manufacturers with comprehensive accounts payable recovery audit services. The client operates through a highly decentralized global structure, with manufacturing plants, purchasing functions, and payment centers distributed across multiple continents.
This international operating model creates a complex accounts payable environment. Purchasing decisions and supplier transactions originate in numerous countries, while related purchase order, receipt, and payment information resides in separate data sets.
Differences in purchasing practices, pricing structures, and the maturity of regional processes make it difficult to evaluate payment accuracy using a single standardized review. Effective auditing requires the ability to consolidate inconsistent information and compare purchase order terms against receipts and actual paid prices.
The company's substantial international vendor base adds another dimension to the engagement. Obtaining supplier statements, validating outstanding balances, and resolving claims requires outreach that accounts for language and communication differences across markets.
The Challenge
Finding Payment Discrepancies Across a Fragmented Global Network
The client's globally dispersed operations created challenges in consolidating data, validating purchase order terms, and communicating with international suppliers. Before a meaningful audit could begin, Broniec needed to bring together inconsistent financial records and account for differences in regional purchasing and payment processes.
Purchasing Across Numerous Countries
Manufacturing plants and purchasing functions operated across multiple countries. These decentralized activities complicated the consistent application and review of purchasing terms, supplier prices, and payment practices.
Disparate Data Sources
Purchase order, receipt, and related financial information was spread across multiple data sets. These sources first needed to be combined into a usable structure before the auditors could compare information and identify discrepancies.
Inconsistent Pricing and Purchase Order Terms
Aligning purchase order terms with receipt information and actual paid prices was difficult across locations. Pricing inaccuracies and inconsistent records created the potential for discrepancies to remain undetected.
Cross-Payment Identification
A globally distributed structure complicated the identification of cross-payments and financial inconsistencies. Effective review required comparisons that extended beyond individual regional data sets.
Varying Regional Process Maturity
Differences in regional operating practices added complexity to the review. The audit needed to account for varying levels of process maturity while applying consistent principles to payment and pricing validation.
International Vendor Communication
A substantial share of suppliers operated outside the client's domestic market. Obtaining statements and verifying balances required communication across languages and multiple channels, creating concerns about supplier participation and claim resolution.
Global operations can make financial inconsistencies difficult to detect when purchase orders, receipts, and payments cannot be evaluated together. The client needed an audit strategy that combined cross-region data analysis with effective international supplier engagement.
The Broniec Approach
Unifying Global Transaction Data and Engaging Suppliers in Their Local Languages
Broniec conducts an annual comprehensive AP recovery audit focused on pricing accuracy, purchase order compliance, and international vendor engagement. The approach combines data consolidation, detailed transaction analysis, and direct supplier communication to investigate discrepancies across the client's decentralized operations.
Consolidate Purchase Order and Receipt Data
Broniec combined disparate purchase order and receipt information into a unified analytical structure. This allowed auditors to compare purchasing records and pricing across sources that otherwise could not be reviewed consistently.
Validate Pricing and Purchase Order Compliance
Auditors examined purchase orders, receipts, and paid prices to identify incomplete or incorrect pricing, internal inconsistencies, value spikes, and transactions that warranted additional reasonableness review.
Investigate Consignment Pricing Discrepancies
Broniec investigated discrepancies involving consignment transactions, including cases where underlying problems pointed to incorrect unit costs. This analysis helped distinguish pricing issues from other transaction inconsistencies.
Conduct Multilingual Supplier Outreach
To overcome the challenges of an internationally distributed vendor base, Broniec used mail, fax, email, and direct calls. Statement requests were translated into the vendors' local languages, improving clarity and supporting the verification of balances and claims.
Overcoming Communication Barriers to Support Claim Resolution
Local-Language Statement Requests
Translating requests into each vendor's local language helped suppliers understand the information needed and respond more effectively.
Multiple Communication Channels
Mail, fax, email, and direct telephone calls allowed Broniec to pursue responses through the methods available to each international supplier.
Direct Balance Validation
Telephone outreach played an important role in confirming vendor balances, clarifying discrepancies, and supporting claim resolution.
Consistent Annual Review
The recurring audit program provided continued review of pricing, purchase order compliance, and international supplier activity.
Multinational AP recovery requires more than combining financial files. The audit must account for different purchasing practices, compare pricing across fragmented records, and engage suppliers in ways that support reliable communication. Broniec's approach addressed both the analytical and relationship-based challenges of international auditing.
Findings & Results
Strong International Vendor Engagement and More Effective Pricing Analysis
Broniec's multinational audit approach helped address two critical challenges: evaluating pricing accuracy across inconsistent global data sources and securing participation from international vendors. The audit established a unified basis for pricing analysis and achieved a strong supplier response rate through multilingual communication.
Overcoming the Challenges of International Vendor Outreach
The client initially questioned whether a globally distributed supplier base would participate effectively in the recovery process. Broniec used translated statement requests and multiple communication methods, achieving an 80% response rate from international vendors. Direct telephone contact was especially valuable in verifying balances and resolving claims.
Consolidated Pricing Visibility
Combining disparate purchase order and receipt records created a unified basis for comparing purchasing terms and prices across the client's international operations.
Pricing Exceptions Investigated
Detailed analysis examined incomplete or incorrect pricing, internal inconsistencies, value spikes, and reasonableness exceptions across purchase orders, receipts, and paid amounts.
Unit-Cost Issues Identified
Investigation of consignment-related discrepancies connected underlying problems to unit-cost errors, providing a more specific understanding of the factors affecting transaction accuracy.
Stronger Balance Verification
Local-language requests and direct vendor communication improved supplier participation and played an important role in confirming balances and supporting claim resolution internationally.
Supporting a Recurring Global Recovery Audit Program
Consistent Annual Examination
Nearly two decades of engagement have provided continuity for annual AP recovery audits focused on pricing, purchase order compliance, and international supplier activity.
International Audit Capability
The combination of global data analysis and multilingual outreach demonstrated an effective method for investigating discrepancies and communicating with suppliers across markets.
The engagement illustrates how a structured multinational AP audit can address fragmented purchasing data, investigate pricing inconsistencies, and strengthen international supplier participation. The 80% response rate shows the importance of localized communication alongside detailed financial analysis.
The source case study reports an 80% international vendor response rate and describes pricing analysis and claim resolution activities. It does not specify a total dollar amount identified or recovered; no financial recovery figure is attributed to this engagement.
Let's Start a Conversation
Are Your Global AP Operations Hiding Payment Discrepancies?
Decentralized purchasing, multiple financial systems, inconsistent pricing, and international supplier relationships can complicate payment accuracy and recovery. Broniec Associates helps multinational organizations evaluate complex AP data, investigate discrepancies, and engage suppliers across markets through experienced audit professionals.
Global recovery auditing requires consistent financial analysis, adaptability across local processes, and effective communication with suppliers worldwide.
