Case Study

Higher Education AP Recovery Audit Internal Controls

Bringing Control to a Decentralized AP Model

How Broniec Associates helped a private university uncover previously undetected overpayments and payment discrepancies, identify weaknesses across disconnected financial systems, and recommend a more consistent approach to purchasing and payment oversight.

Audit Impact Greater Visibility. Stronger Controls. Significant overpayments identified across decentralized accounts payable operations. Audit findings supported targeted recommendations for purchasing cards, consolidated billing, and improved financial oversight.

Client Context

Decentralized Purchasing Across a Complex Campus

A private university operated under a decentralized accounts payable model in which individual departments independently initiated purchase requisitions, approved invoices, and issued payments. While this approach gave departments direct responsibility for their purchasing activity, it also fragmented financial oversight across the institution.

Several standalone, non-integrated payment platforms added complexity. With payment information distributed across different systems, departments could not consistently determine whether an invoice had already been paid elsewhere on campus.

This limited visibility increased exposure to duplicate payments, overlooked vendor credits, and other accounts payable discrepancies. The absence of a single point of validation also made it difficult to reconcile purchasing activity across departments and identify recurring errors.

Broniec Associates was engaged to evaluate financial discrepancies within the university's decentralized operations and provide insight into opportunities for strengthening payment accuracy and internal controls.

The Challenge

Limited Visibility Across Departments and Payment Systems

The university's decentralized accounts payable structure created multiple points of financial exposure. Individual departments controlled purchasing and payment activity, while disconnected systems prevented consistent validation of transactions across the institution.

Decentralized Payment Authority

Departments independently initiated requisitions, approved invoices, and issued payments. This distributed responsibility made university-wide financial oversight difficult and increased the potential for inconsistent payment controls.

Disconnected Financial Systems

Multiple standalone payment platforms operated without integration, limiting the university's ability to compare transactions or review historical payments across departments.

Inconsistent Duplicate Payment Checks

Because prior-payment information was not consistently available across systems, departments could not reliably verify whether an invoice had already been paid. This created heightened duplicate payment risk.

Overlooked Vendor Credits

Fragmented purchasing and payment information made outstanding credits more difficult to identify and reconcile. Credits associated with individual departments could remain unresolved without a consolidated view of supplier activity.

Limited Cross-Department Reconciliation

The university lacked a consistent means of reconciling transactions across payment platforms and operating groups. This made it more difficult to detect discrepancies that extended beyond a single department.

No Centralized Financial Validation

Without a central point of payment oversight, the institution had limited visibility into financial activity across campus. This reduced the ability to identify systemic weaknesses and apply consistent purchasing controls.

The Underlying Risk

When individual departments manage payments through separate systems, errors can remain invisible beyond the department in which they occur. The university needed independent analysis capable of identifying discrepancies across its fragmented AP environment and highlighting opportunities for more effective institution-wide controls.

The Broniec Approach

Combining Technology and Auditor Expertise to Identify Hidden AP Discrepancies

Broniec Associates conducted a comprehensive recovery audit using a two-level methodology. Proprietary technology helped identify transaction-level discrepancies, while experienced auditors conducted more detailed reviews of financial categories requiring professional judgment. The findings also informed recommendations for improving purchasing and payment controls.

Technology-Driven Payment Analysis

Broniec applied proprietary audit tools to identify duplicate payments and unapplied vendor credits. This analysis helped uncover discrepancies that could be obscured by the university's disconnected financial platforms and decentralized payment activity.

Detailed Auditor Review

Experienced Broniec auditors extended the analysis beyond automated matching, examining sales and use tax inaccuracies, unclaimed property exposure, freight discrepancies, and pricing and contract deviations.

Identification of Control Weaknesses

The audit provided insight into discrepancies occurring across the university's decentralized purchasing operations. Findings helped identify process weaknesses and opportunities to improve payment accuracy and financial oversight.

Targeted Purchasing Recommendations

Based on the initial audit findings, Broniec recommended changes to the university's purchasing structure, including the use of purchasing cards and a more consolidated billing approach to improve transparency and reduce manual processing.

Recommended Control Improvements

Moving Toward a More Consistent Purchasing Structure

Introduce Purchasing Cards

Broniec recommended purchasing cards (P-Cards) as a way to simplify purchasing activity, improve oversight, and provide a more consistent approach to managing departmental spending.

Consolidate Billing and Payment Visibility

Moving toward a consolidated billing structure could help reduce fragmented processing, improve transaction visibility, and strengthen the university's ability to identify duplicate payments and unresolved credits.

Why This Approach Mattered

The combination of technology-driven analysis and experienced auditor review allowed Broniec to look beyond individual departmental transactions. By identifying financial discrepancies and the underlying control weaknesses, the engagement provided both recovery opportunities and practical direction for improving the university's AP operating model.

Findings & Results

Uncovering Financial Discrepancies and Opportunities for Stronger Controls

Broniec's audit revealed significant overpayments and financial discrepancies across the university's decentralized accounts payable operations. The findings extended beyond individual payment errors, highlighting opportunities to improve purchasing processes, transaction validation, and institution-wide oversight.

Overall Audit Impact Recovery and Control Improvement Financial findings paired with practical operational recommendations.

Beyond Identifying Overpayments

The audit uncovered significant payment discrepancies that had gone undetected across departmental operations. In addition to supporting financial recovery, Broniec identified underlying weaknesses and recommended targeted improvements to purchasing and payment controls.

Payment Accuracy

Duplicate Payments Identified

The audit identified duplicate and other payment discrepancies within the university's decentralized operating environment. These findings illustrated the risk of processing invoices without consistent access to institution-wide payment history.

Vendor Balances

Unapplied Credits Uncovered

Broniec's analysis revealed previously overlooked vendor credits, demonstrating how decentralized supplier activity can make available funds difficult to identify through routine processing.

Additional Audit Categories

Tax, Freight, and Contract Discrepancies

Experienced auditors examined additional risk areas, including sales and use tax, freight charges, pricing and contract compliance, and unclaimed property exposure, providing a broader view of financial discrepancies.

Financial Oversight

Root Causes and Control Gaps Identified

Beyond detecting payment errors, Broniec connected findings to weaknesses associated with fragmented systems and decentralized payment authority. These insights informed recommendations for improving transaction visibility and controls.

Supporting Long-Term Financial Improvements

Greater Purchasing Transparency

Recommendations for purchasing cards and consolidated billing offered a practical path toward better visibility into campus-wide purchasing activity and more consistent financial controls.

More Disciplined AP Operations

Audit findings helped the institution recognize opportunities to reduce manual processing, strengthen transaction checks, and limit future overpayments across departmental operations.

The Lasting Value

The engagement demonstrated how an independent AP recovery audit can uncover financial discrepancies while identifying the structural factors that allow errors to occur. Broniec's findings provided both meaningful recovery opportunities and a foundation for stronger financial oversight across the university.

The source case study describes significant overpayments and financial recovery but does not specify a dollar amount. Purchasing cards and consolidated billing were recommended improvements; their implementation was not documented.

Let's Start a Conversation

Is Decentralized Purchasing Creating Hidden Financial Risk?

Disconnected payment systems, distributed purchasing authority, and limited transaction visibility can make duplicate payments, unresolved credits, and other discrepancies difficult to detect. Broniec Associates helps organizations identify financial recovery opportunities and understand where stronger AP controls may be needed.

Independent financial review can help connect the dots across complex AP environments, revealing overlooked discrepancies and opportunities for more consistent purchasing oversight.